Say cheeeese to

your new fav.

Female owned/operated

Best pizza in orlando finalist, 2022

Featured in times square, nyc

ORDER NOW

BEST PIZZA IN ORLANDO FINALIST

Slice to meet ya!

Now Delivering!

ORDER NOW

Order Now!

What can we get for you today?

Our Menu

BEST SELLERS

STARTERS

PIZZAS

WINGS

SALADS

BEST SELLERS

Buttercrust Pepperoni

Our signature Buttercrust with crispy pepperoni

Jumbo Chicken Wings

6, 12, or 20 bone-in wings, in your choice of 5 delicious flavors

Cheese Bombs

Mozzarella-stuffed dough topped with butter and house garlic blend

Buttercrust Bianca

Alfredo base, garlic, ricotta, spinach, finished with a nut-free basil pesto swirl

STARTERS

Parmesan Butter Bites

Sharable oven-baked breadstick bites brushed with garlic, butter and parmesan cheese

Cheese Bombs

Mozzarella-stuffed dough topped with butter and house garlic blend

Pepperoni Pinwheels

Cheesy pinwheels rolled up with marinara and pepperoni

Spinach-Artichoke Pinwheels

Cheesy pinwheels rolled up with spinach and artichokes

PIZZAS

Build Your Own

Choose from classic round, Buttercrust original square, or cauliflower (GF) crust

Kickin' Hawaiian

Ham, bacon, and sweet chili pineapple

Supreme

Pepperoni, sausage, peppers, mushrooms, onions, black olives, finished with a red sauce swirl

Bruschetta

The owner's special house-made bruschetta, finished with a balsalmic and nut-free pesto swirl

Meatlover

Pepperoni, bacon, ham, sausage, meatball, finished with a red sauce swirl

Plantlover

Peppers mushrooms, onions, black olives, spinach, roasted peppers, finished with a nut-free basil pesto swirl

BBQ Chicken

Chicken, red onion, smoked gouda cheese, fniished with a BBQ swirl

Bianca

Alfredo base, garlic, ricotta, spinach, finished with a nut-free basil pesto swirl

Buffalo Chicken

Chicken tossed in buffalo, onions, cheddar, finished with a buffalo and ranch swirl

Triple Mac & Cheesiest

Cavatappi white cheddar macaroni and cheese, topped with chedder, jack, mozzarella and sprinkled with bread crumbs

WINGS

Jumbo Chicken Wings

6, 12, or 20 bone-in wings, in your choice of 5 delicious flavors

SALADS

Caesar Salad

Romaine, parmesan, croutons

Bruschetta Salad

Iceberg Lettuce, shredded mozzarella, house-made bruschetta, black olives, cucumbers

Check out our different crusts!

ORDER NOW

Our Customers' Favorite

Buttercrust Signature Pepperoni

ORDER NOW

Why choose us?

Glad You Asked...

Fresh Ingredients

Our team specializes in making delicious and mouth watering food for you, your family and your friends. We don’t believe in cutting corners on flavor, so we make sure we are only providing you with the highest quality ingredients available to the pizza industry. We spend time on creating the dough, crust, sauce and toppings- so we want to make sure that those ingredients are second to none.

We Knead The Dough

Every day, we make pizza dough. We have a different process in making our round dough and our square Buttercrust dough. Our Buttercrust dough takes about five hours (yes, FIVE) to make. We take pride in the process and love to share our crispy edges with our airy, fluffy dough base.

We're Local!

We are a female-owned and independently operated sole location that was born in Orlando, and has plans to grow as far as our pizza dreams will take us!

What's everyone saying?

Believe the hype.

Best kept secret in Orlando. Hands down the best pizza in the city. Make sure you get the square buttercrust pepperoni.

Jon

We eat pizza.....too often. And this is some of the best pizza we've ever had. We're already plotting our return

Hayley

Oh. My. God. Came here during a business trip. Wasn’t expecting pizza this good in Florida. If I could leave a million stars I would!

Nicholas

Best pizza and customer service I have ever had! I will definitely be back again. This is my new favorite and only pizza place.

Niseni

THE BEST 10/10!! The crust is buttery & delicious! I highly recommend the mac & cheese pizza. They also have the best staff. Every time we have been, they make us feel very welcome!

Kara

The pizza is absolutely delicious. I am a very picky pizza person and I find most places pretty gross and greasy unless I make it myself. ButterCrust is so yummy we keep going back for more!!

Cassandra

We had a square cheese/red sauce pizza. Crunchy crust, buttery Airy Center with pesto drizzle. Pizza was Delicious. I'm excited for leftovers.

Scott

This pizza was absolutely delicious. We had the square butter crust pizza. Kathy was so helpful, she worked with me on coordinating a pickup for the airport as I had 2 starving passengers waiting on us. It was piping hot like she promised. We all loved it!

Mary Jane

First time at Buttercrust tonight and IT DID NOT DISAPPOINT AT ALL!!!!! Awesome, delicious, and flavorful pizza! We will definitely be back!!!

Michelle

Brianna Feldman

The Big Cheese

Welcome to Buttercrust Pizza!!! I moved to Orlando to attend UCF several years ago from Connecticut. When I lived in CT, I worked at a pizza shop in New Milford, and ever since, it has been a dream of mine to open a pizza shop of my own!

We offer takeout and delivery. All of our menu items are made with the highest quality ingredients: fresh, handcut meats & veggies, dough made in-house daily, Grande cheese, and the most delicious sauce (my own recipe). Thank you for visiting our website and I can't wait to see you soon!

Like free pizza?

Join our VIP club.

Name Field is required

E-mail Field is required Incorrect email

Phone Field is required

How did you hear about us? Field is required

Your message was sent successfully

Sorry, your message was not sent

Store Hours

Sunday-Thursday
11:00am-10:00pm

Friday-Saturday:
11:00am-11:00pm

How can we help you?

Contact Us

Name Field is required

E-mail Field is required Incorrect email

Phone Field is required

Message Field is required

Your message was sent successfully

Sorry, your message was not sent