Say cheeeese to your new fav.

Female owned/operated

Best pizza in Orlando finalist, 2022 & 2023

Featured in Times Square NYC, Eater.com, and More

Join our loyalty program

Earn Points & Save Money

Weekly specials

Both Locations

House-Made Dough

We make all of our dough in house daily

Fresh Ingredients

We slice, dice, and chop all of our toppings

Pickup & Delivery

Delivery is offered through UberEats and Doordash

You WanNA Pizza Me?

Shareables

Cheese Bombs, Pinwheels, & More

Specialty Pies/Build Your Own Pizza

Choose From Ours or Get Creative!

Twice-Baked Wings

Never Fried!

Desserts

Try Our Sweet Treats!

Believe The Hype

Best kept secret in Orlando. Hands down the best pizza in the city. Make sure you get the square buttercrust pepperoni.

Jon

We eat pizza.....too often. And this is some of the best pizza we've ever had. We're already plotting our return

Hayley

Best pizza & customer service I have ever had! I will definitely be back again. This is my new favorite and only pizza place.

Niseni

Oh. My. God. Came here during a business trip. Wasn’t expecting pizza this good in Florida. If I could leave a million stars I would!

Nicholas

We had a square cheese/red sauce pizza. Crunchy crust, buttery Airy Center with pesto drizzle. Pizza was Delicious. I'm excited for leftovers.

Scott

First time at Buttercrust tonight and IT DID NOT DISAPPOINT AT ALL!!!!! Awesome, delicious, and flavorful pizza! We will definitely be back!!!

Michelle

THE BEST 10/10!! The crust is buttery & delicious! I highly recommend the mac & cheese pizza. They also have the best staff. Every time we have been, they make us feel very welcome!

Kara

This pizza was absolutely delicious. We had the square butter crust pizza. Kathy was so helpful, she worked with me on coordinating a pickup for the airport as I had 2 starving passengers waiting on us. It was piping hot like she promised. We all loved it!

Mary Jane

The pizza is absolutely delicious. I am a very picky pizza person and I find most places pretty gross and greasy unless I make it myself. ButterCrust is so yummy we keep going back for more!!

Cassandra

Meet The Big Cheese

Slice to meet ya! My name is Brianna, and I moved to Orlando to attend UCF almost twenty years ago from Connecticut. I had worked at a pizza shop in New Milford, and ever since, it has been a dream of mine to open a pizza shop of my own!

All of our menu items are made with the highest quality ingredients: fresh, hand cut meats & veggies, two styles of dough made in-house daily, Grande cheese, and the most delicious sauce (my own recipe). Check out our different crust options- I made sure to offer a variety for the whole family.

Thank you for visiting our website and I can’t wait to see you soon!

Say cheeeese to your new fav.

Hand-Tossed

Buttercrust Pan

Ultra Thin

Gluten Free

Join our loyalty program